Suggestions by @matthewshapiro

Ben Barnes

as John Marston in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Jon Bernthal

as Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +2

Vince Gilligan

as Director in Red Dead Redemption

Score: +1

Cate Blanchett

as Catherine Braithwaite in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Leviticus Cornwall in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -3

Ed Harris

as Andrew Milton in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +5

Noah Schnapp

as Jack Marston (Teen) in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -6

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Josiah Trelawny in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +15

Emma Watson

as Mary-Beth Gaskill in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +2

Emma Thompson

as Mary-Beth Gaskill in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -5

Amandla Stenberg

as Tilly Jackson in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +8

William Fichtner

as Leopold Strauss in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +4

Donald Glover

as Lenny Summers in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: +6

Jason Momoa

as Charles Smith in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -4

Charlize Theron

as Sadie Adler in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -1

Gerard Butler

as Dutch Van Der Linde in Red Dead Redemption (TV Show)

Score: -2