Suggestions by @marian

Riley Voelkel

as Astrid in The Charmed Legacy

Emmy Rossum

as Claire Asher in The Charmed Legacy

Kasia Smutniak

as Marya Zaleska in My Universal Horrors Franchise

Crispin Glover

as Dracula in My Universal Horrors Franchise

August Wittgenstein

as Dracula in My Universal Horrors Franchise

Richard Armitage

as Igor in My Universal Horrors Franchise

Charles Dance

as Abraham Van Helsing in My Universal Horrors Franchise

Matthew McNulty

as Gabriel Van Helsing in My Universal Horrors Franchise

August Wittgenstein

as Count Dracula in Dracula

Emmy Rossum

as Sarah in Angel Sanctuary

Henry Cavill

as Leviathan in Angel Sanctuary

Tom Welling

as Abaddon in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Brian Krause

as Leo in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Rose McGowan

as Paige in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Alyssa Milano

as Phoebe in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Holly Marie Combs

as Piper in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Matthew McNulty

as Rhosh in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Sam Witwer

as Aiden Sawyer "Samael" in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Melissa Benoist

as Melinda Halliwell in Charmed. The Dark Generation

Phoebe Tonkin

as Tamora Mitchell in Charmed. The Dark Generation