Suggestions by @maiax

Lovie Simone

as Filippa in If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio

Jordan Fisher

as Oliver in If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio

Jessica Alba

as Aphrodite in Greek Gods (Reincarnated)

Jess Bush

as Persephone in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Harry Styles

as Dionysus in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Timothée Chalamet

as Hermes in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Henry Cavill

as Apollo in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Oscar Isaac

as Hephaestus in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Jessica Alba

as Aphrodite in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Jesse Williams

as Ares in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Genevieve O'Reilly

as Demeter in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Kerry Washington

as Hera in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Anson Mount

as Zeus in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Yvonne Strahovski

as Artemis in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Rosamund Pike

as Athena in Greek Gods and Goddesses and Heroes

Zendaya Coleman

as Meredith in If We Were Villains

Sydney Sweeney

as Meredith in If We Were Villains

Brittany O'Grady

as Fillipa in If We Were Villains

Jesse James Keitel

as Meredith in If We Were Villains

Diana Silvers

as Wren in If We Were Villains