Suggestions by @madiburback

Zoë Kravitz

as Charlie in To Paradise

Score: +1

Mahershala Ali

as Young Nathaniel in To Paradise

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Peter in To Paradise

Score: +1

Jonathan Majors

as Edward in To Paradise

Score: -2

Rob Morgan

as Old Edward in To Paradise

Score: +1

Jesse Plemons

as Charles in To Paradise

Score: +4

Oscar Isaac

as The Husband in To Paradise

Score: +1

Justice Smith

as Book 3 David in To Paradise

Score: +1

Dev Patel

as Book 3 Final David in To Paradise

Score: +1

Jeffrey Wright

as Old Kawika in To Paradise

Score: +1

Joe Alwyn

as David Bingham in To Paradise

Score: +2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Kevin Murphy in We Are Not Like Them

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Shaun Wilson in We Are Not Like Them

Score: +1

Victoria Pedretti

as Jen Murphy in We Are Not Like Them

Score: +1

Alexandra Shipp

as Riley Wilson in We Are Not Like Them

Score: +1

Chad Michael Murray

as Tom Benton in The Love Hypothesis

Score: 0

Diana Silvers

as Lucy Gray Baird in The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes

Score: -12

Kaya Scodelario

as Linsdey Lee Wells in An Abundance of Katherines

Score: 0