Suggestions by @maddiem

Shay Rudolph

as Grace Blakely in All Fall Down

Score: +1

Madison Iseman

as Grace Blakely in Embassy Row Series

Score: +1

Liana Liberato

as Peyton Sawyer in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -1

Iris Apatow

as Haley James in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +1

Bebe Wood

as Brooke Davis in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +3

Harris Dickinson

as Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -1

Medalion Rahimi

as Priya Gupta in All Your Twisted Secrets

Score: +4

Diana Silvers

as Rose Hathaway in Vampire Academy & Bloodlines Epic Dream Cast

Score: -8

Lorenzo Zurzolo

as Adrian Ivashkov in The Vampire Academy

Score: +1

Bebe Wood

as Angeline Dawes in The Vampire Academy

Score: +3

Diana Silvers

as Rose Hathaway in The Vampire Academy

Score: +1