Suggestions by @lvettraino

Rudy Pankow

as Aaron Warner in Shatter Me

Score: -60

Raini Rodriguez

as Myrtle Wilson in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +3

Rebecca Ferguson

as Jordan Baker in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +2

Henry Cavill

as Tom Buchanan in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +1

Lucy Boynton

as Daisy Buchanan in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +3

Dacre Montgomery

as Gatsby in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +2

James McAvoy

as Nick Carraway in Great Gatsby 4.0

Score: +1