Suggestions by @lurkedawg
7 suggestions
Colin Farrell
as The Penguin in James Gunn's DC Universe
+4-2Score: +2
Rhett McLaughlin
as Hank Hall in James Gunn's DC Universe
+4-0Score: +4
Paul Dano
as The Riddler in James Gunn's DC Universe
+11-5Score: +6
Derek Theler
as Aric of Dacia (X-O Manowar) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)
+1-1Score: 0
Joseph Morgan
as Brian Braddock (Captain Britain) in All Superheroes and Villains (DC, Marvel, & Dark Horse Comics)
+7-1Score: +6
Joseph Morgan
as Brian Braddock in Marvel Cinematic Universe
+15-14Score: +1
Joseph Morgan
as Captain Britain in Captain Britain
+2-3Score: -1