Suggestions by @lunaclark
62 suggestions
Arrow Rhodes Ackles
as Sally in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe
Liam Hemsworth
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Nicholas Hoult
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Aaron Taylor-Johnson
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Armie Hammer
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Jeremy Allen White
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Ethan Cutkosky
as Terrence Afton in The Afton Family
Dylan McDermott
as Vincent Afton in The Afton Family
Joseph Fiennes
as Vincent Afton in The Afton Family
Cheyenne Jackson
as Vincent Afton in The Afton Family
John Stamos
as Vincent Afton in The Afton Family
Hans Matheson
as William Afton in The Afton Family
Cooper Barnes
as William Afton in The Afton Family
Ian Somerhalder
as William Afton in The Afton Family
Tristan Hemsworth
as Christopher/Evan Afton in The Afton Family
Jamie Kennedy
as Christopher/Evan Afton in The Afton Family
Ambree Orgill
as Elizabeth Afton in The Afton Family
Ana Luiza Sparrapan
as Elizabeth Afton in The Afton Family
Valeria García Díaz
as Elizabeth Afton in The Afton Family
Elena Satine
as Clara Afton in The Afton Family