Suggestions by @lukejamesbennett

Tobey Maguire

as Jack Frost in Rise of the Guardians (2002)

Score: +1

John Cena

as Nega Chin in The Fairly Oddparents (Live Action tv show)

Score: +4

Jennifer Holland

as Golden Locks in The Fairly OddParents (livecast)

Score: +4

John Cena

as Nega Chin in The Fairly OddParents (livecast)

Score: +4

Jennifer Holland

as Golden Locks in Fairly Odd Parents

Score: +4

John Cena

as Nega Chin in Fairly Odd Parents

Score: +4

The Nega-Chin

as Cary Grant in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Score: +4

The Crimson Chin

as Cary Grant in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Score: +4

Barry Duffman (The Simpsons)

as Cary Grant in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Score: +4

Catman (Fairly Oddparents)

as James Stewart in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Score: +4

Golden Locks

as Katharine Hepburn in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?

Score: +4

The Nega-Chin

as Boris Karloff in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Score: +4

The Crimson Chin

as Boris Karloff in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Score: +4

Barry Duffman (The Simpsons)

as Boris Karloff in What characters would you like to hear voice actors voice?

Score: +4

The Nega-Chin

as Boris Karloff in Which characters would you like voice actors to play

Score: +4

The Crimson Chin

as Boris Karloff in Which characters would you like voice actors to play

Score: +4

Barry Duffman (The Simpsons)

as Boris Karloff in Which characters would you like voice actors to play

Score: +4

The Nega-Chin

as Boris Karloff in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Score: +4

The Crimson Chin

as Boris Karloff in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Score: +4

Barry Duffman (The Simpsons)

as Boris Karloff in Deceased Actors’ Casting You Would’ve Loved to See

Score: +4