Suggestions by @lovelydarkness28
344 suggestions
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Penny Peabody in Riverdale (1980s)
BD Wong
as Reggie Mantle in Riverdale (1980s)
Theresa Saldana
as Veronica Lodge in Riverdale (1980s)
Daphne Ashbrook
as Alice Cooper in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Stacey Dash
as Michaela Pratt in How to Get Away with Murder (1994-2000)
Brandon Lee
as Cameron in The Summer I Turned Pretty (1983-1987)
Haviland Morris
as Gigi in The Summer I Turned Pretty (1983-1987)
Hunter Parrish
as Cal Price in Love, Simon (2004)
Melinda Clarke
as Gladys Jones in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Joshua Jackson
as Nick Nelson in Heartstopper (2003-2007)
Brooke Shields
as Tessa Young in After (1986)
Justin Chon
as Reggie Mantel in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Amanda Seyfried
as Polly Cooper in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Milo Ventimiglia
as Jughead Jones in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Mischa Barton
as Betty Cooper in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Lindsay Lohan
as Cheryl Blossom in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Willa Holland
as Jellybean Jones in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Michelle Pfeiffer
as Alice Cooper in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Bianca Lawson
as Toni Topaz in Riverdale (2007-2014)
Vanessa Hudgens
as Veronica Lodge in Riverdale (2007-2014)