Suggestions by @louissmith

Heather Langenkamp

as Michelle Shipman in The Final Girl Support Group

Tom Noonan

as Gerald Scott in Pretty Girls

John David Washington

as Montgomery in The Island of Dr. Moreau (Reboot)

Michael Fassbender

as Edward Prendick in The Island of Dr. Moreau (Reboot)

Robert De Niro

as Dr. Moreau in The Island of Dr. Moreau (Reboot)

Kevin Spacey

as Edwin Van Wees in Pieces of Her

Frances Conroy

as Clara Bellamy in Pieces of Her

Thandiwe Newton

as Alexandria Maplecroft in Pieces of Her

Margot Robbie

as Andy Oliver in Pieces of Her

Jeff Bridges

as Carl Huckabee in Pretty Girls

Donald Trump

as Ronald Rich in Hostel 4

Matthew McConaughey

as Paul Scott in Pretty Girls

Zach Galifianakis

as Rick Butler in Pretty Girls

Billy Bob Thornton

as Gerald Scott in Pretty Girls

Willem Dafoe

as Gerald Scott in Pretty Girls