Suggestions by @louieidk

Cynthia Erivo

as Terpsichore in Hercules

Idris Elba

as Buffalo Man in American Gods

Cooper Andrews

as Officer Chad Mulligan in American Gods

Jayme Lawson

as Bast in American Gods

Harry Shum Jr.

as Mr. Wood in American Gods

Wes Bentley

as Mr. Stone in American Gods

William H. Macy

as Hinzelmann in American Gods

Eman Esfandi

as Salim in American Gods

Jade Hassouné

as Jinn in American Gods

Jovan Armand

as Technical Boy in American Gods

Maggie Geha

as Media in American Gods

Taron Egerton

as Low-Key Lyesmith in American Gods

Alan Tudyk

as Mr. Town in American Gods

Grace Dove

as Marguerite Olsen in American Gods

Phoebe Dynevor

as Misery Chastain in Misery

Elva Guerra

as Sam in American Gods

Vera Farmiga

as Zorya Vechernyaya in American Gods

Helen Mirren

as Zorya Utrennyaya in American Gods

Taissa Farmiga

as Zorya Polunochnaya in American Gods

Rachel Sennott

as Laura in American Gods