Suggestions by @loreguyt

Richard Brake

as Anwir in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Jed Brophy

as Grûblik in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Joseph Gatt

as The Hammer of Sauron in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Derek Mears

as The Tower of Sauron in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Winston Duke

as Serka in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Chadwick Boseman

as Baranor in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Jessica Chastain

as Calántiel in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Phil LaMarr

as Ratbag in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +3

Anya Chalotra

as Eryn in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Andy Serkis

as Gollum in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Claire Forlani

as Queen Marwen in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Ewan Mitchell

as The Black Hand of Sauron in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Paul Bullion

as Hirgon of Tarnost in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Adam Driver

as Lord Asgon in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

James Cosmo

as Hallas in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Robert Aramayo

as Dírhael in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

Gemma Arterton

as Ioreth in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Cate Blanchett

as Galadriel in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +2

Katheryn Winnick

as Lithaeriel in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +3

Katherine Winnick

as Lithariel in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1