Suggestions by @loreguyt

Mason Dye

as Firwë in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Peter Jackson

as Gratuitous cameo in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Mark Wahlberg

as Torvin Stiffbeard in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: 0

John Hannah

as Torvin Stiffbeard in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Matt Ryan

as Torvin Stiffbeard in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Amanda Henderson

as Gwînn Ironfist in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

John Rhys-Davies

as Gimli in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Orlando Bloom

as Legolas in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Ian McKellen

as Gandalf in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Viggo Mortensen

as Aragorn in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Khary Payton

as Serka - Jagai in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Wil Johnson

as Sefut in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Jóhannes Haukur Jóhannesson

as Forthog in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Peter Franzén

as Dagor in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Lawrence Makoare

as Gothmog in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Lawrence Makoare

as Ûtt in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Daniel Kaluuya

as Serka - Jagai in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1

Robert Kazinsky

as Ar-Brûz - the Chopper in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Glasha in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: +1

Bobby Lockwood

as Firwë in The Shadows of Mordor - Retold

Score: -1