Suggestions by @lifeisgood

Sadie Sink

as Phoebe Lawton in One of Us is Next

Mckenzie Small

as Yrene Towers in Throne of Glass Series

Gabrielle Union

as Sadie Corcoran in Two Can Keep A Secret

Rachel Weisz

as Alicia Kelly in Two Can Keep A Secret

Rudy Pankow

as Kyle McNulty in Two Can Keep A Secret

Tyler Alvarez

as Officer Ryan Rodriguez in Two Can Keep A Secret

Dylan O'Brien

as Declan Kelly in Two Can Keep A Secret

Isabela Merced

as Brooke Bennett in Two Can Keep A Secret

Levi Miller

as Malcolm Kelly in Two Can Keep A Secret

Asher Angel

as Malcolm Kelly in Two Can Keep A Secret

Brec Bassinger

as Katrin Nilsson in Two Can Keep A Secret

Jacob Elordi

as Declan Kelly in Two Can Keep A Secret

Abby Donnelly

as Viv Cantrell in Two Can Keep A Secret

Sadie Sink

as Viv Cantrell in Two Can Keep A Secret

Jenna Ortega

as Brooke Bennett in Two Can Keep A Secret

Natasha Liu Bordizzo

as Daisy Kwon in Two Can Keep A Secret

Adeline Rudolph

as Daisy Kwon in Two Can Keep A Secret

Nathaniel Potvin

as Ezra Corcoran in Two Can Keep A Secret

Sofia Bryant

as Ellery Corcoran in Two Can Keep A Secret

Madison Bailey

as Celeste in The Selection Series