Suggestions by @liammitchell

Diesel La Torraca

as Eric in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Leslie Mann

as Debbie in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Lily James

as Cassie in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Elisha Cuthbert

as Sandy in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Zachary Gordon

as Noah in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Pete in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Britt Robertson

as Sara in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +2

Naomi Scott

as Mermaid in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Shelley Hennig

as Avery in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Brandon Flynn

as Cal in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Tom Felton

as Sayge in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +1

Jessica Belkin

as Tiffany in The Black Room

Score: +1

Brie Larson

as Emily in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +2

Andi Matichak

as Maddy in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +2

Jack Champion

as Adam in American Horror Story Cruise Ship

Score: +3

Kevin Spacey

as Arthur in The Black Room

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Troy’s Father in The Black Room

Score: +2

Felix Mallard

as Troy in The Black Room

Score: +2

Liana Liberato

as Vicki in The Black Room

Score: +2

Callan McAuliffe

as Hunter in The Black Room

Score: +2