Suggestions by @leonlincoln

Brendan Fraser

as Superman in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Casting Heroes and Villains

Score: +2

Kevin Spacey

as Lex Luthor in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Casting Heroes and Villains

Score: +1

Paul Walker

as Aquaman in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Casting Heroes and Villains

Score: +1

Matthew Nable

as Johnny Klebitz in GTA V

Score: +5

Danis Tanović

as Writer in The Balkan Day

Score: +1

Ahmed Imamović

as Producer in The Balkan Day

Score: +1

Feđa Štukan

as Senad Hodzic in The Balkan Day

Score: +1

Michael Jai White

as Balrog in Street Fighter Live Action Movies

Score: +10

Nathan Fillion

as Green Lantern 3 in Justice League DCU 2027

Score: +2

Pierre Niney

as Remy LeBeau in GAMBIT

Score: +6

Pierre Niney

as Remy LeBeau in Marvel Studios' Gambit (Disney+)

Score: +9

Scarlett Pomers

as Raven Darkhölme in Marvel's Gambit

Score: +2

Kyle Lowder

as Johnny Blaze in Ghost Rider MCU Movie

Score: +6

Emma Watson

as Barbara Gordon/Batgirl in Batman/Ghost Rider: Dark Vengeance

Score: +2