Suggestions by @leahwilson

Helena Bonham Carter

as Limos in Elevator to Tartarus

Meryl Streep

as Daphne in Elevator to Tartarus

Melissa McCarthy

as Janet in Elevator to Tartarus

Kathryn Hahn

as Metaneira in Elevator to Tartarus

Amy Schumer

as Iambe in Elevator to Tartarus

Alec Baldwin

as Helios in Elevator to Tartarus

Givēon

as Orpheus in Elevator to Tartarus

Keke Palmer

as Eurydice in Elevator to Tartarus

Domhnall Gleeson

as Morpheus in Elevator to Tartarus

Neil Patrick Harris

as Paris in Elevator to Tartarus

Matt Bomer

as Achilles in Elevator to Tartarus

Katherine Heigl

as Cammy in Elevator to Tartarus

Timothée Chalamet

as Hyacinthus in Elevator to Tartarus

Cara Delevingne

as Penthesilea in Elevator to Tartarus

Harvey Guillén

as Greg in Elevator to Tartarus

Maya Rudolph

as Themis in Elevator to Tartarus

Steve Carell

as Sisyphus in Elevator to Tartarus

Tilda Swinton

as Arcadian Priestess in Elevator to Tartarus

Zoe Kazan

as Leuce in Elevator to Tartarus

Paul Rudd

as Iasion in Elevator to Tartarus