Suggestions by @kylecooke

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Arthur Gibson in The Gibson Family Christmas

Score: -2

Carly Chaikin

as CIA Agent Iris Kennedy in Stalemate

Score: -1

Jane Levy

as Maya Brandt in Stalemate

Score: -1

Vincent D'Onofrio

as Paul Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Katherine McNamara

as Stacey Lambert in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Madelaine Petsch

as Samantha "Sam" Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Nina Dobrev

as Audrey Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Chris Carmack

as Scott Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Kellie Martin

as Victoria Lambert in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Dacre Montgomery

as Hayden Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

KJ Apa

as Mark Truman in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Kevin Zegers

as Ben Truman in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Michael Wincott

as Paul Perry in Step Siblings

Score: -1

Dylan Sprayberry

as Daniel "Danny" Lambert in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Wyatt Oleff

as Charles "Charlie" Lambert in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Lizzy Greene

as Monica Lambert in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Brock Brenner

as Joey Perry in Step Siblings

Score: +1

Megan Fox

as Zoe Briggs in Stalemate

Score: -1

Eiza González

as Zoe Briggs in Stalemate

Score: -1

Eiza González

as Annabel Croft in Stalemate

Score: -1