Suggestions by @kylan2001

Paul Bettany

as Jonathan Crane in Batman

Score: +1

Nate Mann

as Bruce Wayne in Batman

Score: +1

Nate Mann

as Batman in Batman: The Brave and the Bold Live Action

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Death in Supernatural

Score: +1

Julian Richings

as Death in Supernatural

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Famine in Supernatural

Score: +1

Ed Harris

as Pestilence in Supernatural

Score: +1

Paul Bettany

as War in Supernatural

Score: +1

Joe Manganiello

as Cain in Supernatural

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Cain in Supernatural

Score: +1

Mark Ruffalo

as Metatron in Supernatural

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as The Darkness in Supernatural

Score: +1

Dylan Minnette

as Harry Osborn in Spiderman 4

Score: 0

Ty Simpkins

as Jack Kline in Supernatural

Score: +1

Saxon Sharbino

as Bella Talbot in Supernatural

Score: +1

Gerard Butler

as Benny Lafitte in Supernatural

Score: +1

Adelaide Kane

as Lisa Braeden in Supernatural

Score: +2

Phoebe Tonkin

as Madison in Supernatural

Score: +1

Peter Sarsgaard

as Alistair in Supernatural

Score: +1

Travis Fimmel

as Asmodeus in Supernatural

Score: 0