Suggestions by @kumagom

Jason Momoa

as Nightmare Bonnie in Into The FNAFverse

Liam Hemsworth

as Nightmare Freddy in Into The FNAFverse

Bill Skarsgård

as Phantom Puppet in Into The FNAFverse

Rahul Kohli

as Phantom Balloon Boy in Into The FNAFverse

Amandla Stenberg

as Phantom Mangle in Into The FNAFverse

Rihanna

as Phantom Chica in Into The FNAFverse

Chris Evans

as Phantom Foxy in Into The FNAFverse

Chris Pratt

as Phantom Freddy in Into The FNAFverse

Elijah Wood

as X.O.R in Into The FNAFverse

Steve Buscemi

as Shadow Balloon Boy in Into The FNAFverse

Martin Freeman

as Shadow Puppet in Into The FNAFverse

Rob Schneider

as RWQFSFASXC in Into The FNAFverse

Chris Rock

as Shadow Freddy in Into The FNAFverse

Kevin James

as JJ in Into The FNAFverse

Mike Myers

as Withered Foxy in Into The FNAFverse

Madonna

as Withered Chica in Into The FNAFverse

Al Pacino

as Withered Bonnie in Into The FNAFverse

Jack Nicholson

as Withered Freddy in Into The FNAFverse

Sylvester Stallone

as Helpy in Into The FNAFverse

Zendaya

as Vanessa in Into The FNAFverse