Suggestions by @koolove101

Olivia Rodrigo

as Santana Lopez in Glee (Recasting)

Score: +6

Stephanie Beatriz

as Santana Lopez in Glee (Recasting)

Score: 0

Olivia Rodrigo

as Rachel Berry in Glee (Recasting)

Score: +8

Sabrina Carpenter

as Chris Hargensen in Carrie

Score: +1

Naya Abou Mousa

as Sue Snell in Carrie

Score: +1

Sabrina Carpenter

as Sue Snell in Carrie

Score: 0

Patricia Arquette

as Margaret White in Carrie

Score: +2

Nicole Kidman

as Sarah Sanderson in Hocus Pocus

Score: -2

Sabrina Carpenter

as Leah Birch in Big Mouth

Score: +4

Freddie Mercury

as Ghost of Freddie Mercury in Big Mouth

Score: +4

Joshua Bassett

as Andrew Glouberman in Big Mouth

Score: -2

Grant Gustin

as Jordan McAfee in Salem Falls

Score: +2

Barbie Ferreira

as Meg in Salem Falls

Score: +1

Lady Gaga

as Starshine in Salem Falls

Score: +3

Grant Gustin

as Best Smile in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: +6

Allyson Grant

as Best Smile in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: 0

Grant Gustin

as Most Attractive (Male) in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: +2

Paris Hilton

as Best Reality Star (Female) in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: +4

Evan Peters

as Prom King in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: +1

Sabrina Carpenter

as Prom Queen in Hollywood Superlatives

Score: +12