Suggestions by @knight_ofgotham
39 suggestions

Amy Acker
as Pieck Finger in Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin) (2000s)

Jim Caviezel
as Captain Levi Ackerman in Attack on Titan (Shingeki no Kyojin) (2000s)

Donald Sutherland
as Batman in 80's Justice League fancast (please read synopsis)

Rachel Bilson
as Zatanna Zatara in Batman/Spider-Man

Grace Caroline Currey
as Mary Jane Watson in Batman/Spider-Man

Daniel Sharman
as Richard Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Ian McShane
as Carmine Falcone in Batman/Spider-Man

Vince Vaughn
as Wilson Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Michael Chiklis
as Wilson Fisk in Batman/Spider-Man

Daniel Gillies
as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Michael Fassbender
as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Cameron Cuffe
as Peter Parker in Batman/Spider-Man

Jim Caviezel
as Bruce Wayne in Batman/Spider-Man

Amy Acker
as Zatanna Zatara Wayne in Hellbat

Brenton Thwaites
as Peter Parker in MCU Reboot Fancast

Emilia Clarke
as Zatanna Zatara in Superman: New Krypton

Jenna Coleman
as Huntress in Every Batman Character

Ben Barnes
as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: Gotham by Gaslight (2007)

Jane Levy
as Mary Jane Watson in Amazing Spider Man 3 (2023)

Erik Oleson
as Director in Batman: Gotham By Gaslight Season 1