Suggestions by @kittycat02

Tasha Scott

as Delta James in Luann (1990 TV Movie)

Score: 0

Sara Gilbert

as Bernice Halper in Luann (1990 TV Movie)

Score: +2

Candace Cameron Bure

as Luann DeGroot in Luann (1990 TV Movie)

Score: +2

Ralph Macchio

as John Brooke in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Tom Cruise

as Theodore "Laurie" Laurence in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Jade Pettyjohn

as Teen Luann (flashback;2020s) in How I think Luann DeGroot would be cast throughout the decades

Score: +2

Jonathan Bennett

as Teen Aaron (2000s) in How Aaron Hill would’ve been cast through every decade

Score: +2

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Young Aaron (mid-late 1990s) in How Aaron Hill would’ve been cast through every decade

Score: +2

Jonathan Brandis

as Young Aaron (early 1990s) in How Aaron Hill would’ve been cast through every decade

Score: +3

Kelly Rowland

as Teen Delta (2000s) in How I think Delta James would be cast throughout the decades

Score: +2

Mandy Moore

as Teen Tiffany (2000s) in How Tiffany Farrell would be cast throughout the decades

Score: 0

Meryl Streep

as Marmee in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Elisabeth Shue

as Older Amy March in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Candace Cameron Bure

as Young Amy March in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Jennifer Connelly

as Beth March in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Lea Thompson

as Meg March in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Ally Sheedy

as Jo March in Little Women (1988)

Score: +2

Katherine Heigl

as Teen Tiffany (2000s) in How Tiffany Farrell would be cast throughout the decades

Score: +2

Larisa Oleynik

as Younger Tiffany (mid-late 1990s) in How Tiffany Farrell would be cast throughout the decades

Score: +2

Ami Foster

as Younger Tiffany (early 1990s) in How Tiffany Farrell would be cast throughout the decades

Score: +2