Suggestions by @kingredpanda

Cade Woodward

as Gabriel in Five Nights

Score: +1

Madeleine McGraw

as Cassidy in Five Nights

Score: +1

Quinn McCarthy

as Elizabeth Afton in Five Nights

Score: +1

Matthew Patrick

as Phone Guy in Five Nights

Score: +1

Josh Gad

as Mike Schmidt in Five Nights

Score: +1

Eric Bauza

as Bonnie in Five Nights

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as William Afton in Five Nights

Score: +1

Chris Evans

as Micheal Afton in Five Nights

Score: +2

Tara Strong

as Chica in Five Nights

Score: +1

Matthew Patrick

as Micheal Afton in Five Nights

Score: +1

Mark Hamill

as Freddy in Five Nights

Score: +2

Richard Jenkins

as Henry in Five Nights

Score: +1

Isaac Harger

as Evan Afton in Five Nights

Score: +3