Suggestions by @kbrian082

Ethan Embry

as Carter Davis in Happy Death Day 2 U (1999)

Ethan Embry

as Carter Davis in Happy Death Day (1997)

Wil Wheaton

as Tal in Nick & Norah's Infinite Playlist (1998)

Tobey Maguire

as Alan Pinkard in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Archie Kao

as Jasper Kwong in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Ioan Gruffudd

as Eric Mardian in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Ethan Suplee

as Dennis Blunden in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Rosario Dawson

as Sarah Nevins in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Tyra Banks

as Darlene Merriman in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

Rosario Dawson

as Darlene Merriman in Head of the Class (1996-2001)

John Goodman

as Tazer in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Danny DeVito

as Skip in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Steve Carell

as Sparks in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Oliver Phelps

as Lee Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

James Phelps

as Art Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

David Lynch

as Director in River's Edge (1996)

Jane Krakowski

as Nina Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Ted Danson

as Stu Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Stephen Root

as Nate Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Tom Pearson in Aliens in the Attic (1999)