Suggestions by @kalebanglin

Danny Pudi

as Diddy Kong in The Super Mario World Movie (Illumination)

Score: +1

James Patrick Stuart

as Thelonious in Shrek/Puss in Boots: The Fairytale Saga

Score: +1

Griffin (Hotel Transylvania)

as Kuzco in What Will Fictional Characters Be for Halloween? (My Version)

Score: +1

Patrick Warburton

as Blag in The Wild 2

Score: +4

No Voice

as Phil in Madagascar 4

Score: +2

Conrad Vernon

as Mason in Madagascar 4

Score: +2

David Schwimmer

as Melman the Giraffe in Madagascar 4

Score: +2

Jada Pinkett Smith

as Gloria the Hippo in Madagascar 4

Score: +1

Conrad Vernon

as Rico in Madagascar 4

Score: +2

Richard Kind

as Larry in The Wild 2

Score: +4

Greg Cipes

as Ryan in The Wild 2

Score: +3

Janeane Garofalo

as Bridget in The Wild 2

Score: +3

Eddie Izzard

as Nigel in The Wild 2

Score: +5

Jim Belushi

as Benny in The Wild 2

Score: +4

JP Karliak

as Big Jack Horner in Who should voice the Puss in Boots: The Last Wish characters in a video game?

Score: +2

Kellen Goff

as Death the Wolf in Who should voice the Puss in Boots: The Last Wish characters in a video game?

Score: +3

Harvey Guillén

as Perrito in Who should voice the Puss in Boots: The Last Wish characters in a video game?

Score: +2

Cristina Valenzuela

as Kitty Softpaws in Who should voice the Puss in Boots: The Last Wish characters in a video game?

Score: +6