Suggestions by @jtnolan
971 suggestions
Winona Ryder
as Lana Lang in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Billy Zane
as Oliver Queen in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Jared Padalecki
as The Mutant Leader in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Summer Fontana
as Carrie Kelly in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Laurence Fishburne
as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Hugh Laurie
as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Hugo Weaving
as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Paul Bettany
as Mayor of Gotham in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Michael Shannon
as Mayor of Gotham in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
James Marsden
as Mayor of Gotham in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Gary Oldman
as James Gordon in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Bryan Cranston
as James Gordon in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Milla Jovovich
as Ellen Yindel in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Olivia Colman
as Ellen Yindel in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Geoffrey Rush
as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Johnny Depp
as Joker in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Peter Capaldi
as Joker in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Jon Hamm
as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Viggo Mortensen
as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Jeffrey Dean Morgan
as Bruce Wayne/Batman in Batman: The Dark Knight Returns