Suggestions by @jsleister

Mark Harmon

as Hamilton Hill in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Ethan Hawke

as Jim Gordon in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: 0

Richard Madden

as Harvey Dent in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: 0

Blake Lively

as Vicky Vale in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Dina Meyer

as Sarah Essen in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Jason Clarke

as Peter Grogan in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Michael Madsen

as Arnold Flass in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Harvey Dent in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: 0

David Harbour

as Harvey Bulkock in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +2

J.K. Simmons

as Aaron Cash in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Ray Winstone

as Joe Chill in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Adrian Pasdar

as Salvatore Maroni in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Olivia Wilde

as Martha Wayne in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Emily Blunt

as Barbara Kean-Gordon in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Connie Nielsen

as Jocelyn Kilroy in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as Sebastian Hardy in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Jim Caviezel

as Thomas Wayne in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Alexander Skarsgård

as Mario Falcone in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Sam Witwer

as Floyd Layton in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1

Mahershala Ali

as Crispus Allen in Batman: Year One(story removed)

Score: +1