Suggestions by @jonnyg

Jeff Conaway

as Angel in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Mark Hamill

as Iceman in 1970's X-Men

Score: +2

Gene Wilder

as Beast in 1970's X-Men

Score: +2

Lou Ferrigno

as Juggernaut in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

George Steele

as Blob in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Ann-Margret

as Lorelei in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Brad Dourif

as Toad in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Sonny Chiba

as Sunfire in 1970's X-Men

Score: +2

Jan-Michael Vincent

as Cyclops in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Wolverine in 1970's X-Men

Score: +2

Christopher Lee

as Magneto in 1970's X-Men

Score: +5

Richard Kiel

as Unus the Untouchable in 1970's X-Men

Score: +1

Donald Pleasence

as Bolivar Trask in 1970's X-Men

Score: +2

Catherine O'Hara

as Hermione Lodge in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

Christina Applegate

as Melody Valentine in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

David Lee Roth

as Soundtrack #15 in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

Sigue Sigue Sputnik

as Soundtrack #14 in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

Chuck Berry

as Soundtrack #13 in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

Tears for Fears

as Soundtrack #12 in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1

The Cure

as Soundtrack #11 in Archie Andrews, Where Are You? (1988)

Score: +1