Suggestions by @johnawalker

Skyler Samuels

as Helen Hamilton in Starcrossed

Claudia Lee

as Helen Hamilton in Starcrossed

Natalie Alyn Lind

as Helen Hamilton in Starcrossed

Ciara Bravo

as Cassandra Delos in Starcrossed

India Eisley

as Cassandra Delos in Starcrossed

Ali Larter

as Carol Young in After

Liam Hemsworth

as Hardin Scott in After

Candice King

as America Mason in Beautiful Disaster

Cameron Crovetti

as Oak in The Cruel Prince

Douglas Booth

as Locke in The Cruel Prince

Gerard Butler

as Balekin Greenbriar in The Cruel Prince

Margot Robbie

as Oriana in The Cruel Prince

Alexander Skarsgård

as Dain Greenbriar in The Cruel Prince

Zendaya

as Nicasia in The Cruel Prince

Zoey Deutch

as Jude Duarte in The Cruel Prince

Hayden Panettiere

as Donatella in Caraval

Dominic Sherwood

as Jacks in Caraval

Nico Tortorella

as Julian in Caraval

Nina Dobrev

as Scarlett in Caraval

Matthew Daddario

as Dante in Caraval