Suggestions by @jobby

Peter Bergman

as Glorfindel in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Lynda Carter

as Arwen in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Norman Lloyd

as Tom Bombadil in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Leonard Nimoy

as Lord Elrond in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Richard Thomas

as Peregrine Took in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Murray Head

as Meriadoc Brandybuck in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Alan Rickman

as Boromir, prince of Gondor in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Brian Blessed

as Gimli, son of Gloin in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Rutger Hauer

as Legolas Greenleaf in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Jackson Bostwick

as Aragorn II Elessar in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Robin Williams

as Samwise Gamgee in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Leonard Whiting

as Frodo Baggins in The Lord of The Rings

Score: +1

Harry Lennix

as Lock in The Matrix Reloaded (my version)

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Neo in The Matrix Reloaded (my version)

Score: 0

D.J. Cotrona

as Clark Kent/Superman in Superman Man of Steel (2009)

Score: +1

Nicholas Hoult

as Bruce Wayne in Quest of The Demon

Score: +1

Peter Lorre

as Oswald "Oz" Cobblepot in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)

Score: +4

Boris Karloff

as Mystery Arkham Inmate in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)

Score: +2

Pat Hingle

as Commissioner James Gordon in My Burtonverse

Score: +1

Alec Guinness

as Alfred Pennyworth in My Burtonverse

Score: +1