Suggestions by @jillianmaria

Letitia Wright

as Billie in Livingston Girls

Amanda Seyfried

as King in Livingston Girls

Bridget Satterlee

as June in Livingston Girls

Joshua Anthony Brand

as Eddie in Livingston Girls

Henry Cavill

as Blake in Livingston Girls

Madelaine Petsch

as Charlie in Livingston Girls

Indya Moore

as Regan Pierce in Ashwood Grove

Angélica

as Morgana Woods in Ashwood Grove

Hynden Walch

as Morgana Woods in Ashwood Grove

Heather Graham

as Morgana Woods in Ashwood Grove

Sophie Vincent

as Emma in Ashwood Grove

Piper Mackenzie Harris

as Emma in Ashwood Grove

Helena Barlow

as Emma in Ashwood Grove

Jordyn Jones

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Emily Alyn Lind

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Bella Podaras

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Natalie Alyn Lind

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Chiara Aurelia

as Kristen in Ashwood Grove

Raffey Cassidy

as Kristen in Ashwood Grove

Danielle Rose Russell

as Kristen in Ashwood Grove