Suggestions by @ jayydubb

Sam Elliott

as Detective Gordon in Batman Evolution

David Howard Thornton

as The Joker in Batman Evolution

Peter Capaldi

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Evolution

Austin Butler

as Nightwing in Batman Evolution

+0-2Score: -2

Andrew Lincoln

as Batman in Batman Evolution

+0-1Score: -1

Alan Ritchson

as Batman in Batman Evolution

David Harbour

as Batman in Batman Evolution

+2-3Score: -1

Karl Urban

as Dave Grohl (Old) in Through Dave's Eyes

Matt Barr

as Taylor Hawkins in Through Dave's Eyes

Karl Urban

as Dave Grohl in Music BioPics

Jared Leto

as Andy Biersack in Musician Biopics

Andre Anthony

as Brendon Urie in Musician Biopics

Paul Rudd

as Coraline's Father in Coraline Live Action

Andy Samberg

as Coraline's Father in Coraline Live Action

Jenna Ortega

as Coraline Jones in Coraline Live Action

+2-4Score: -2

Matt Rife

as Jack Frost in (Live action) Rise Of The Guardians

Max Charles

as Jack Frost in (Live action) Rise Of The Guardians

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Santa Claus in (Live action) Rise Of The Guardians

Jason Momoa

as Santa Claus in (Live action) Rise Of The Guardians