Suggestions by @jayydubb

Andy Biersack

as The Joker in Batman Evolution

Score: +1

Austin Butler

as The Joker in Batman Evolution

Score: 0

Cameron Monaghan

as The Joker in Batman Evolution

Score: -1

Florence Pugh

as 2020s in What Actresses Could've Played Sienna Shaw in Various Decades?

Score: +2

Emma Myers

as 2020s in What Actresses Could've Played Sienna Shaw in Various Decades?

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as Nevershoutnever! in Musician Biopics

Score: +1

David Bradley

as Alferd in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Rowan Atkinson

as Alferd in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Michael D. Cohen

as Penguin in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +2

Dirk Blocker

as Penguin in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Warick Davis

as Penguin in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Joker in Batman Arkham Trilogy

Score: 0

Jon Hamm

as Two Face in Batman Evolution

Score: +1

Michael Rosenbaum

as Two Face in Batman Evolution

Score: -1

Alexander Molony

as Damian Wayne in Batman Evolution

Score: +1

Bill Goldberg

as Bane in Batman Evolution

Score: -2

Dylan O'Brien

as Nightwing in Batman Evolution

Score: -1

Bill Nighy

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman Evolution

Score: +3

Archie Yates

as Millhouse in The Simpsons

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Homer in The Simpsons

Score: +1