Suggestions by @jasleenfaydelarosa
4,375 suggestions
Martin Sheen
as Mr. Tanner in Fraternity Boy (Sorority Girl 1987 Genderswap)
Score: +6
Barbara Cowan
as Skye Rotter in What Character Do You Want to Barbara Cowan play in the 50s
Score: +5
Barbara Cowan
as Allison Reynolds in What Character Do You Want to Barbara Cowan play in the 50s
Score: +5
Barbara Cowan
as Megan Gordon in What Character Do You Want to Barbara Cowan play in the 50s
Score: +5
Steve McQueen
as Andrew Clark in The Breakfast Club (1955)
Score: +3
Barbara Cowan
as Allison Reynolds in The Breakfast Club (1955)
Score: +6
Debbie Reynolds
as Claire Standish in The Breakfast Club (1955)
Score: +5
James Dean
as John Bender in The Breakfast Club (1955)
Score: +6
Vanessa Palmer
as Debbie Reynolds in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Score: +6
Hope Lange
as Laura Lee in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +6
Debbie Reynolds
as Young Vanessa Palmer in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +5
Lucille Ball
as Vanessa Palmer in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +5
Nancy Kilgas
as Young Misty Quigley in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +5
Diahann Carroll
as Young Taissa Turner in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +6
Barboura Morris
as Young Shauna Shipman in Yellowjackets (50s)
Score: +5
Roger Corman
as Director in Jennifer (1958)
Score: +5
Nancy Kilgas
as Valerie Hartman in '80s Actors in the '50s
Score: +5
Taissa Turner
as Diahann Carroll in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Score: +5
Misty Quigley
as Nancy Kilgas in Which characters should actors have played in the '50s?
Score: +5
Nancy Kilgas
as Norma Watson in Carrie (1956)
Score: +6