Suggestions by @jackoreilly

Kedar Williams-Stirling

as Avery Hawksworth in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Helena Howard

as Alisha Winger in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Keira Knightley

as Andromeda Black in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Lamar Johnson

as Rabastan Lestrange in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Victoria Pedretti

as Miriam Strout in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Jack Quaid

as Stephen Gould in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Charlie Heaton

as Alastor Moody in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Joe Keery

as Bozo in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Jason Segel

as Broderick Bode in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Claire Foy

as Dolores Umbridge in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Katie McGrath

as Bellatrix Black in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Cillian Murphy

as Alphard Black in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Cheyenne Isabel Wells

as Siobhan Montgomery in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Simu Liu

as Dedalus Diggle in Marauders Era Fancast Help

George MacKay

as Arthur Weasley in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Marilyn Monroe

as Hope Howell in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Eva Green

as Walburga Black in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Colin Firth

as Orion Black in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Dev Patel

as Fleamont Potter in Marauders Era Fancast Help

Dev Patel

as Fleamont Potter in Marauders Era Fancast Help