Suggestions by @ivankarp

Edward G. Robinson

as Pew in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Ned Glass

as Pew in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Peter Lorre

as Pew in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Buster Keaton

as Ben Gunn in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Charlie Chaplin

as Ben Gunn in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Ed Wynn

as Ben Gunn in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Rex Harrison

as Captain Smollett in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Robert Newton

as Billy Bones in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Robert Morley

as Squire Trelawney in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

John Wayne

as Captain Smollett in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Christopher Lee

as Captain Smollett in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Kirk Douglas

as Dr. Livesey in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Rock Hudson

as Dr. Livesey in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Gregory Peck

as Dr. Livesey in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Orson Welles

as Long John Silver in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Burl Ives

as Long John Silver in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Jon Provost

as Jim Hawkins in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Jerry Mathers

as Jim Hawkins in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Nicholas Hammond

as Jim Hawkins in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1

Martin Stephens

as Jim Hawkins in Treasure Island (1963)

Score: +1