Suggestions by @itsmematt

Ian McKellen

as Magneto in The House of M

Score: +3

Emma Dumont

as Polaris in The House of M

Score: +2

Evan Peters

as Quicksilver in The House of M

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Scarlet Witch in The House of M

Score: +5

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as The Maximoff's Neighbor in The House of M

Score: +2

John Krasinski

as Mr. Fantastic in The House of M

Score: +4

Keanu Reeves

as Kraven the Hunter in The House of M

Score: +4

Timothée Chalamet

as Speed in The House of M

Score: -1

Finn Wolfhard

as Wiccan in The House of M

Score: -2

Mark Wahlberg

as Peter Maximoff in MCU X-Men

Score: -8

Evan Peters

as Peter Maximoff in MCU X-Men

Score: 0