Suggestions by @itsalmostmidnight

Mike Myers

as Shrek in Meme Cinematic Universe Phase 2 Cast

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Shaggy in Meme Cinematic Universe Phase 2 Cast

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as SwordOfLands in MyCast Users

Score: +2

Keanu Reeves

as Director in The Story of America

Score: +1

Aaron Paul

as Director in The Story of America

Score: +1

Barbie

as Anya Taylor Joy in Which characters would you like to see actors play in live-action

Score: +8

Mark Strong

as Mr. Freeze in The Batman Universe

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as The Joker in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Rory McCann

as George Mason in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +2

Nicholas Hoult

as Nathan Hale in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +3

Eric Idle

as King George III in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +2

Martin Freeman

as James Monroe in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +3

Adrien Brody

as Benedict Arnold in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +2

Kyle MacLachlan

as Andrew Jackson in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +3

Aaron Eckhart

as Ethan Allen in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +2

Tom Glynn-Carney

as Marquis de Lafayette in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +2

Colin Farrell

as Hercules Mulligan in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +4

Stanley Tucci

as Samuel Adams in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +3

Gaspard Ulliel

as Marquis de Lafayette in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: -3

Toby Jones

as John Adams in Freedom And Justice For All

Score: +3