Suggestions by @isabellawilson

Freddie Highmore

as Byron Swain in Witch and Wizard

Anthony Carrigan

as The One in Witch and Wizard

Julia Roberts

as Eliza Allgood in Witch and Wizard

Keke Palmer

as Jamilla in Witch and Wizard

Britt Robertson

as Margo in Witch and Wizard

Selena Gomez

as Janine in Witch and Wizard

Isabela Merced

as Celia in Witch and Wizard

Amber Heard

as Celia in Witch and Wizard

Lucas Till

as Whitford Allgood in Witch and Wizard