Suggestions by @infinitynetwork

Carson Severson

as Fred Jones in Mystery Incorporated

Score: -1

Colin Farrell

as Unknown Alias in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Joseph Morgan

as Jim Corrigan in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Rosalie Chiang

as Traci Thirteen in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

David Henrie

as Vance Nelson in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: -1

Miles Teller

as Vance Nelson in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Camila Mendes

as Zatanna Zatara in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Isaak Presley

as Todd Rice in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Austin Butler

as John Constantine in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Nicholas Ryan Hernandez

as Derek James in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Malachi Barton

as Derek James in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Sophie Michelle

as Rachel Roth in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Ian Nelson

as Dick Grayson in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Kylie Rogers

as Kara Zor-El in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Zoe Manarel

as Traci Thirteen in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: -1

Eduardo Minett

as Jaime Reyes in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Eden McCoy

as Courtney Whitmore in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

James Marsden

as Pat Dugan in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Jenna Z. Alvarez

as Jennifer-Lynn Hayden in DC's Mayhem in the Multiverse

Score: +1

Bradley Cooper

as Sebastian Blood VIII in DC's Heroes Join Forces

Score: +1