Suggestions by @imbatman

Anxiety (Inside Out)

as Gelotophobia (Fear of Being Laughed At) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Paul (Inner Workings)

as Coimetrophobia (Fear of Cemetaries, Fear of Funerals) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Evan (Superbad)

as Genophobia (Fear of Sex) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Captain Hook (Peter Pan)

as Batrachophobia (Fear of Amphibians) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Rapunzel (Tangled)

as Trichophobia (Fear of Hair Loss) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Colossus (Piotr Rasputin)

as Astrophobia (Fear of Space) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Martian Manhunter

as Pyrophobia (Fear of Fire) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Yoshi (Mario)

as Capiophobia (Fear of Police) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Hal Jordan (Green Lantern)

as Xanthophobia (Fear of Yellow) in Sorting Characters by Fears

FAKE

as Autophobia (Fear of Isolation, Fear of Loneliness) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Jason Voorhes

as Aquaphobia (Fear of Water) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Son Goku

as Trypanophobia (Fear of Needles) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Freddy Krueger

as Pyrophobia (Fear of Fire) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Steven Universe (Character)

as Ophidiophobia (Fear of Snakes) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Stewie Griffin

as Necrophobia (Fear of Death) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Tom (Tom & Jerry)

as Cynophobia (Fear of Dogs) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Patrick Star

as Arachnophobia (Fear of Spiders) in Sorting Characters by Fears

SpongeBob SquarePants (character)

as Coulrophobia (Fear of Clowns) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Piglet (Winnie the Pooh)

as Agoraphobia (Fear of Open Spaces) in Sorting Characters by Fears

Nancy Thompson

as Oneirophobia (Fear of Dreams) in Sorting Characters by Fears