Suggestions by @iainross

Edward Bosco

as Alastor in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Amir Talai

as Minos in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Luke Millington-Drake

as Lucifer in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Wendell Pierce

as Charon in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Taylor Sheridan

as Dante in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Mads Mikkelsen

as Virgil in Dante's Inferno the Musical

Score: +1

Withered Chica

as Withered Chica in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Withered Bonnie

as Withered Bonnie in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +2

Withered Chica

as Withered Bonnie in Fnaf the Movie

Score: -1

Withered Freddy

as Withered Freddy in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Balloon Boy

as BB in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

The Puppet

as Puppet in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Toy Chica

as Toy Chica in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Toy Bonnie

as Toy Bonnie in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Toy Freddy

as Toy Freddy in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Mangle

as Mangle in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Springtrap

as Springtrap in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Golden Freddy

as Golden Freddy in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Foxy the Pirate Fox

as Foxy in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1

Bonnie the Bunny

as Bonnie in Fnaf the Movie

Score: +1