Suggestions by @hydrostorm87

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Marge Sherwood in The Talented Mr. Ripley (John Malkovich)

Richard E. Grant

as Dickie Greenleaf in The Talented Mr. Ripley (John Malkovich)

John Malkovich

as Tom Ripley in The Talented Mr. Ripley (John Malkovich)

Pablo Schreiber

as Paladin in Have Gun – Will Travel (Film Reboot)

Max von Sydow

as Red Ghost in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Luke Eberl

as Victor Vaughn in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Nicholas Braun

as Ben Grimm (90's) in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Devon Werkheiser

as Reid Richards (90's) in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Cody Kasch

as Victor Vaughn in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Rosamund Pike

as Sue Storm in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Kate Winslet

as Sue Storm in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Timothy Olyphant

as Reid Richards in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Jason Bateman

as Reid Richards in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Brendan Fraser

as Benjamin Grimm in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Cole Hauser

as Benjamin Grimm in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Brendan Fraser

as The Thing in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Cole Hauser

as The Thing in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Zac Efron

as The Thing in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Shia LaBeouf

as The Thing in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)

Brendan Fraser

as The Thing in Johnson's Fantastic Four (2011)