Suggestions by @hydrostorm87

Jennifer Jason Leigh

as Kay Stone in Marty Supreme (2015)

Score: +1

Laura Linney

as Kay Stone in Marty Supreme (2015)

Score: +1

Kevin O'Leary

as Wally in Marty Supreme (2015)

Score: -1

Eliot Sumner

as Safe Cracker in Untitled Heist/Crime movie

Score: +1

Zachary Gordon

as Young Guy Haines in Strangers on a Train

Score: +1

Shia LaBeouf

as Marty Mauser in Marty Supreme (2015)

Score: +4

Dylan O'Brien

as Robert Forrester in The Cry of The Owl

Score: +1

Fess Parker

as Cowboy in Hell or High Water (1972)

Score: +1

Clarence Gilyard Jr.

as Clyde Livingston in Holes (1978)

Score: +1

Ryan Hurst

as Mammoth in Johnson's DCU Villain Roster

Score: +1

Carl Jones

as Coach (Oranges Dad) in Showcall

Score: +1

Shia LaBeouf

as Marty Mauser in Marty Supreme (2015)

Score: +1

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Susan Grimshaw in Read Dead 2029

Score: +2

Katie Holmes

as Susan Grimshaw in Read Dead 2029

Score: +2

Peter Mullan

as Uncle in Read Dead 2029

Score: +2

Nick Nolte

as Jesse Pinkman in Breaking Bad 60s-70s trilogy

Score: +1

James Jordan

as Special Agent Edgar Ross in Read Dead 2029

Score: +2