Suggestions by @hurricaneclub

Sean Harris

as Elijah in Moby Dick

Score: +2

Bill Camp

as Bildad in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Paddy Considine

as Starbuck in Moby Dick

Score: 0

Peter Capaldi

as Peleg in Moby Dick

Score: +2

Dick Gregory

as Fleece in Moby Dick

Score: 0

Matt Berry

as Captain Boomer in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Colman Domingo

as Daggoo in Moby Dick

Score: +2

Mackenzie Crook

as Flask in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Ishmael in Moby Dick

Score: +2

Alex Proyas

as Director in Warcraft

Score: +1

George Miller

as Director in Warcraft

Score: +1

Jonathan Pryce

as Antonidas in Warcraft

Score: +2

Jack Thompson

as Uther The Lightbringer in Warcraft

Score: +1

Alden Ehrenreich

as Ishmael in Moby Dick

Score: +2

Joel Edgerton

as Starbuck in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Stephen Graham

as Stubb in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Terrell Ransom Jr.

as Pip in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Barry Keoghan

as Stubb in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Alexander Siddig

as Fedallah in Moby Dick

Score: +1

Shelley Duvall

as Zeena Krumbein in Tim Burton’s Nightmare Alley (1991)

Score: +2