Suggestions by @https17walten

Mia Goth

as Nina Hopkins in Nina The Killer

Score: +2

Vera Farmiga

as Margaret Woods in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Peter Sarsgaard

as Peter Woods in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Tom Fitzpatrick

as Cursed figure 2 in Slendrina

Score: +1

Joseph Bishara

as Cursed Figure in Slendrina

Score: +1

Jacob Elordi

as Randy in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Joseph Bishara

as Composer in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Leigh Whannell

as Writer in Jane the killer

Score: +1

James Wan

as Director in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Liu Woods in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Ruairí O'Connor

as Jeff Woods in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Ron Livingston

as Bruce Arkensaw in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Frances O'Connor

as Paula Arkensaw in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Jeff Woods in Jane the killer

Score: -1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Liu Woods in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Kristen Stewart

as Jane Arkensaw in Jane the killer

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Jack in Poppy playtime

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Pug A Pillar in Poppy playtime

Score: +1

Jackson Robert Scott

as Bunzo Bunny in Poppy playtime

Score: +1

Jennifer Garner

as Kissy Missy in Poppy playtime

Score: +1