Suggestions by @homestuckfuntimes

Linda Hamilton

as April Ludgate in Parks and Recreation (1989 - 1995)

Cassandra Peterson

as April Ludgate in Parks and Recreation (1989 - 1995)

Lucas Cruikshank

as John Egbert in Homestuck

John Cena

as DAD in Homestuck

Timothée Chalamet

as Eridan Ampora in Homestuck

Toby Fox

as Andrew Hussie in Homestuck

Kristen Stewart

as Kanaya Maryam in Homestuck

Zendaya Coleman

as Jade Harley in Homestuck

Kate McKinnon

as MOM Roxy in Homestuck

Hynden Walch

as Nepeta Leijon in Homestuck

Alison Brie

as Nepeta Leijon in Homestuck

Tara Strong

as Jane Crocker in Homestuck

Scarlett Johansson

as Vriska Serket in Homestuck

Tom Kenny

as Lord English in Homestuck

Jenna Marbles

as Roxy Lalonde in Homestuck

Jacob Hopkins

as Karkat Vantas in Homestuck

Jeremy Renner

as Jake English in Homestuck

Michael Cera

as Jake English in Homestuck

Jared Leto

as Dirk Strider in Homestuck

Stephanie Hsu

as John Egbert in Homestuck