Suggestions by @hologrim

Magnus Sinding

as Carlisle in Twilight

Score: -1

Lance Reddick

as Laurent in Twilight

Score: +1

Forrest Goodluck

as Jacob in Twilight

Score: -2

Elliot Page

as Alice in Twilight

Score: -1

Madelaine Petsch

as Victoria in Twilight

Score: +2

Timothée Chalamet

as Jasper in Twilight

Score: +5

David Tennant

as Aro in Twilight

Score: +3

David Tennant

as Aro in Twilight

Score: +1

Michael Sheen

as Aro in Twilight

Score: +1

Brett Dalton

as Emmett in Twilight

Score: -4

Blake Lively

as Rosalie in Twilight

Score: +1